Scotcharoos Dessert Recipe (2024)

Scotcharoos with Peanut Butter Chips and topped with Reese’s Pieces.

These were served at a Holiday Church pot-luck and my Picky Eater son ate more than he should have. Needless to say he asked me to make them at home!

Watch for a quick Tasty Scotcharoos Video

Servings : 40 | Ready in 1 Hour | Good for Dessert

We’ve all had traditional Scotcharoos with butterscotch chips, but what about Peanut Butter chips instead? WOW! I love it!

I even love the added Reese’s Pieces added on top too. Just a fun combination. This was among the first desserts eaten at a Church Pot Luck recently. Needless to say I had to duplicate it.

I don’t know about you, but when I take something to a Pot Luck I want everyone to love it.

There is nothing worse than taking home most of what you brought. It’s so defeating! Well these Scotcharoos will be devoured, I promise.😉

Of course you can always skip the Peanut Butter chips and use Butterscotch Chips in this Scotcharoos recipe. But why not change it up? Live a little!

How to serve Scotcharoos?

Scotcharoos are best served at room temperature. Take out of airtight container and place on plate and allow to soften up on the counter for 10-15 minutes before serving.

What makes Scotcharoos hard?

No one likes to bite into a hard Scotcharoos. It’s like eating Captain Crunch and tearing up your mouth! haha…

Scotcharoos become hard when they are stored in the refrigerator OR when you cook the sugar mixture too long. You only want to cook the sugar mixture until it reaches 125-130 degrees.

Pin this Recipe for Later!

Click the Red Pinterest Save button in the upper left corner of the pictures below

Quick Tips

Melt the chocolate and Peanut Butter Chips in the microwave for 1 ½ – 2 minutes.

Stir after every 30 seconds. OR if you have an Instant Pot, use a large glass bowl to place your chips into and add 3-4 cups of water on Saute’ and heat up the water.

Place the bowl on top and the steam will melt the chips. Brilliant!

Pot Luck Dessert

Did I mention that my Picky Eater ate a bunch of these Scotcharoos and commented how they were so much better than normal Scotcharoos? Well he did!

To the point that he asked me to find out the recipe and make some. haha.. Well after one bite it wasn’t hard to figure out the difference.

By substituting Butterscotch chips for Peanut Butter Chips you have a perfect blent of flavors.

Pot Luck Dessert

Did I mention that my Picky Eater ate a bunch of these Scotcharoos and commented how they were so much better than normal Scotcharoos? Well he did!

To the point that he asked me to find out the recipe and make some. haha.. Well after one bite it wasn’t hard to figure out the difference.

By substituting Butterscotch chips for Peanut Butter Chips you have a perfect blent of flavors.

Don’t stop here, try these other great treat recipes. They are delicious!

• Chocolate Dipped Pecan Sandies Cookies
• Frozen Hot Chocolate
• Candy Dipped Valentine’s Day OREOs
• Leprechaun Dipped OREO’s
• Chocolate Dipped Chips
• Mickey Mouse Candy Dipped Oreos
• Easy Buckeye Pretzels
• Christmas Cookies
• Fancy Marshmallows